Daily Archives: July 22, 2009

Different rules

Scott Bradner has some interesting thoughts on the recent Kindle dust-up and relates it to other cases of “different rules”:

The underlying issue here is that Amazon, among many others, see the rules for digital as different than those for other things. It would never have crossed Amazon’s collective mind to grab a physical book from you if the company had shipped you one that it did not have the right to sell. But, maybe because it could, Amazon just did what it has the ability to do without thinking to see if the ability to do something automatically meant that it was the right thing to do.

Amazon is not alone in confusing the ability to do something with the idea that it is the right thing to do. It would be inconceivable that the U.S. Post Office would be required to make and save a record of who sent and received every letter it handled. Yet, just because it can be done, a number of law enforcement officials have called for laws that require ISPs to do just that with e-mail.

Advertisements

Virtual Directories, O through S

Felix Gaehtgens of Kuppinger Cole has this to say about today’s virtual directory vendors:

As someone actively covering directory services and virtual directories, several innovations have caught my attention. The players within the virtual directory space are (in alphabetical order) Optimal IDM, Oracle, SAP, Radiant Logic, Red Hat, and Symlabs. When it comes to product development and innovation within the last year, you can split those vendors right down the middle. – Optimal IDM, Radiant Logic and Symlabs have been actively developing their product and churning out new features in new versions. The others have not been adding any features, but instead spent time changing logos, product names, default file locations and otherwise integrating the virtual directory products into the respective Oracle/RedHat/SAP identity management ecosystems. In fact, in some of the latter cases I ask myself whether it is likely to expect any virtual directory product innovations anymore.

I couldn’t help but notice that the entire virtual directory space as described by Mr. Gaehtgens spans only five letters of the alphabet (o through s). It doesn’t mean anything, but it’s still odd.