Out-manned and out-gunned

There is this interesting article about new Air Force Cyber Command (AFCYBER) floating a trial balloon about fielding their own botnet to fight an offensive cyber war. From the article:

Second, Williamson makes a pretty decent case for the military botnet; his points are especially strong when he describes the inevitable failure of a purely defensive posture. Williamson argues that, like every fortress down through history that has eventually fallen to a determined invader, America’s cyber defenses can never be strong enough to ward off all attacks. And here, Williamson is on solid infosec ground-it’s a truism in security circles that any electronic “fortress” that you build, whether it’s intended to protect media files from unauthorized viewers or financial data from thieves, can eventually be breached with enough collective effort. 

Given that cyber defenses are doomed to failure, Williamson argues that we need a credible cyber offensive capability to act as a deterrent against foreign attackers. I have a hard time disagreeing with this, but I’m still very uncomfortable with it, partly because it involves using civilian infrastructure for military ends.

The idea (as I understand it) is to use military owned computers to launch a botnet attack as a retaliation against an attack by an enemy.

In this field of battle I fear the AFCYBER is both out-manned and out-gunned. The AF are the go-to guys if you absolutely, positively need something blown up tomorrow. But a DDoS attack? Without compromising civilian hardware, the AF likely couldn’t muster enough machines. Additionally the network locations of the machines they could muster could be easily predicted before the start of any cyber war.

There is an interesting alternative if anyone from AFCYBER is reading this. How about a volunteer botnet force? Civilians could volunteer to download an application that would allow their computer to be used in an AFCYBER controlled botnet in time of a cyber war. Obviously securing this so that it couldn’t be hijacked is a formidable technical challenge, but it’s not insurmountable.

Advertisements

4 responses to “Out-manned and out-gunned

  1. I have an old Palm Pilot sitting in a desk drawer. Do you think I could contribute its use to the volunteer botnet program, or must the machines be American?

    Perhaps the PCs of other countries could be sacrificed in the first wave of fighting, with US PCs reserved for the strategic battles?

    paul

  2. DDoS fodder is always welcome. Any computing entity willing to take packet for the greater good would appreciated.

  3. Pingback: IdentityBlog - Digital Identity, Privacy, and the Internet's Missing Identity Layer

  4. Pingback: The best defense is a good offense, but what kind of offense matters « Identity Blogger

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s